Getting AI to flag problem clauses in contracts, and how far to trust it

It's very good at finding a clause and saying what it does. It isn't a lawyer, and it's weakest exactly where a lawyer is strongest – noticing what's missing. Give it your checklist, make it quote, and keep a person on anything you'd sign.

By Matthew Steele4 min read28 October 2026

A printed contract on a desk with three clauses marked in pencil and a one-page checklist beside it, a laptop screen blurred in the background
Illustrative scene, not a customer's premises.

What it does well

Finding things. Point it at a 40-page agreement and ask where the limitation of liability is and what it says, and it'll find it, quote it and explain it in plain words faster than anyone in the building. Same for payment terms buried in a schedule, a renewal clause that turns silence into a three-year commitment, or an indemnity that only runs one way. If your sales or operations team signs supplier and customer agreements without a lawyer on every one, this is a real step up from skimming.

What it does badly

What's missing. A contract with no limitation of liability at all is the most dangerous kind, and a tool asked to "find the problems" won't mention a clause that isn't there. It has to be told to look for each item and to report when one is absent.

How clauses interact. A reasonable cap in one clause can be undone by a carve-out in another. The tool reads clauses. A lawyer reads the agreement.

Your commercial context. Whether a 90-day payment term is a problem depends on your cash position and the customer. The tool doesn't know that, so it'll either flag everything or nothing.

The checklist method

The checklist drives the reviewYour checklist with positions on each item. The tool finds each clause, quotes it exactly, says whether it meets the position, and reports not found where it cannot find one. A named person reads the flags and quotes. Written triggers decide whether a lawyer looks: anything not found, uncapped liability, exclusivity, high value, unfamiliar jurisdiction. Otherwise, sign.Your checklistEight to twelve items withyour position on each.The toolFinds, quotes exactly, compares,and says "not found".A personReads the flags and the quotes.Twenty seconds a flag.TriggersNot found. Uncapped liability.Exclusivity. Value. Jurisdiction.A lawyer looksSignQuoting is the control. A flag with the clause quoted word for wordis checked in seconds, and an invented quote is caught on the first read.The tool is weakest at what is absent. The checklist tells it to look.
The checklist drives the review. The tool finds and quotes, a person decides, and written triggers say when a lawyer looks.

Write your position on each item once, with your lawyer if you have one, and that becomes the checklist the tool works from.

Item Your position (example) What the tool pulls out
Limitation of liability Capped at the contract value, no uncapped indemnities The clause, quoted, the cap, and anything carved out
Indemnities Mutual, limited to third-party claims Who indemnifies whom, and for what
Payment terms 30 days, no pay-when-paid Days, triggers, penalties
Termination For convenience on 30 days' notice, both sides Who may terminate, when, with what notice
Intellectual property We keep ours, the customer gets a licence to use what we deliver Who owns what gets created
Exclusivity and non-compete None Any restriction on who else you may work with
Renewal No automatic renewal beyond one year Term, renewal mechanism, notice window
Governing law Your jurisdiction The named law and courts

Then the instruction, in plain words: for each item, find the clause and quote it exactly. Say whether it meets the position. If you can't find it, say "not found". Don't summarise anything you haven't quoted.

Make it quote

The quoting is the control. A flag that says "the liability clause looks unfavourable" takes a person 20 minutes to verify. A flag that says "clause 14.2 reads: … which exceeds the position of a cap at contract value" takes 20 seconds – the reviewer reads the quote and either agrees or doesn't. It also makes invention visible, because a quote that isn't in the document gets caught on the first check. Everything in validating what AI produces applies here.

The two-stage review

Every contract: the tool runs the checklist, and a named person reads the flags and the quotes. Some contracts: a lawyer, and the triggers that send it to one are written down in advance, so the decision isn't made under time pressure. The usual triggers are any item marked "not found", any uncapped liability, any exclusivity, any contract over an agreed value, and any counterparty in a jurisdiction you don't normally work in. The tool makes the first stage fast and the second stage rarer. It doesn't replace either one.

Where to run it

Contracts sit in the confidential ring, and anything under a non-disclosure agreement is restricted. That means a company workspace with training switched off, the file uploaded for the review and removed afterwards, no agent in the loop, and the output read by a person before it goes anywhere. Protecting IP and company data has the conditions in full.